User blog comment:Kuzlalala/Lala's Long but Orderly Put Theory about Phineas and Candace's Biological Father/@comment-3473686-20110807015100/@comment-3473686-20110807015709

Here's where it gets odd: he is both dead and alive. You see, Perry just has Phelan's mind. Phelan didn't exactly come back to life, because his soul is still in the afterlife.

Yes, that's what I came up with a while ago. :P Please be nice about it, cuz I'm easily offended...